Planer

An ESRC Investment
Esrc_logo
  • Home
  • About
  • Research
  • Events
  • Blog
Home Homepage Report from transdisciplinary methods for developing nexus capabilities workshop

Report from transdisciplinary methods for developing nexus capabilities workshop

The report from the ‘Transdisciplinary Methods for Developing Nexus Capabilities’ workshop, held at the University of Sussex on 29 and 30 June 2015, is now available.

Download the report as a pdf Transdisciplinary Nexus Methods Workshop final Report 2015

questions

In light of growing challenges in the just, equitable and sustainable global provision of water, food and energy and the complexity of the interactions between these vital systems (the challenges of ‘the Nexus’), participants in the workshop considered the following key questions:

  • What different kinds and interconnections of method in contrasting contexts, form the most practical basis for enabling transformative action to address Nexus challenges?
  • How can such encompassing Nexus methodologies best enable academic, government, business and civil society actors to develop appropriate skills, training and research capabilities?

 

These questions are also addressed in a discussion paper prepared in advance of the workshop by Professor Andy Stirling.

findings

The report elaborates on the ideas and discussions around key themes of the meeting, drawing on input from the speakers and participants. On the first day, participants looked at ‘nexus’ methods, with the concepts outlined in detail by Andy Stirling in his talk. People also focussed on the challenges of working together. Many of the concerns highlighted are not limited to the nexus but could be applicable to any research which crosses subjects and involves participation from different groups.

Despite the concerns highlighted, it was viewed that the challenges of the nexus ‘present an opportunity to develop transdisciplinarity beyond its present limits’.

concerns around transdisciplinary research

The report highlights that ‘transdisciplinary research is complex and time-consuming, especially when it is done in a way which incorporates non-academics’ and that ‘the transdisciplinary approach can also create findings that are complex and hard to apply.’

Communication is key. Even between the researchers this can be a problem; ‘while natural and social scientists have worked together for decades, they often still fail to communicate with each other effectively.’ For example, ‘risk and uncertainty, as understood by natural scientists, can arise from the limits of the scientific method; however social scientists may see them in terms of the complexity of human society’.

Engagement with non-academics: some felt that ‘Nexus research should be participatory throughout’, however this also takes time and money. ‘Nexus-focused research is likely to produce ambiguous answers to important questions. How can we persuade audiences to accept provisional findings that require judgement and interpretation?’ However, it is also important to note that the extent to which researchers in the Nexus community should work with, or act to counter, existing power structures’ was a matter of great contention.

approaches to encourage transdisciplinary research

Some of the suggested approaches from the workshop include

  • Reducing misunderstandings between natural and social scientists, ‘for example, by methods such as decision analysis and by insights from psychology and anthropology’ is needed.
  • Taking the time to understand the priorities of non-academics such as government, business, NGOs and others was felt to be important, yet ‘time-consuimg and difficult’. Suggestions to address this included more placements to exchange people between the sectors.
  • More recognition is needed for the importance of teams in nexus research, and better support for teams in terms of formation and functioning. Suggestions for the use of ‘agile’ research, more common in engineering, where people come in and out of the project depending on the skills needed.
  • The ability to communicate findings, including issues of uncertainty and risk, to a range of people, from the individual householder or farmer to the mutlinational business is important.
  • It was noted that the Nexus Network is mainly a UK activity, despite the global nature of the challenges it seeks to address’, and ‘ways of working appropriate to the global South need to be developed’.

 

Specifically for researchers, the report notes that

  • ‘More capacity needs to be built for transdisciplinary research’ by ‘broadening undergraduate education and the PhD experience’ and by mentoring.
  • Transdisciplinary research can be ‘uncomfortable for researchers who have come through a single-discipline background’. Support for individuals could be improved by funding systems and better career pathways.
  • Hopes were expressed that the next academic Research Excellence Framework assessment will ‘value transdisciplinary impact more highly’ and also that academic ‘quality’ should include a measure of ‘relevance’ to urgent topics, such as food, energy and water, which need to be addressed.

 

What kinds of methods are needed?

Professor Andy Stirling outlined over 100 examples of Nexus-related approaches to a range of problems and projects in his workshop talk. The report notes that ‘choosing an appropriate methodology or methodologies from the plethora of possibilities is itself a challenge, especially given the broad range of data, disciplines and interests that a typical Nexus project must address. No individual researcher is likely to be familiar with all the options. These methodological choices might seem to be a point of detail, but they often reflect the preferences of existing powerful groups. This leads on to a specific concern with mixed methods, expressed by several workshop participants.’

‘Mixed method approaches ought in principle to be flexible and scalable, and therefore ideally suited to research into transdisciplinary/ Nexus-type issues. In practice, research funding panels can be monodisciplinary and unsupportive of mixed approaches.

‘Participants asked what the choice of a method does to the researcher herself and whether methods can be devised that engage people’s emotions and their desire to act, as well as yielding new and systematic knowledge.’

The report concludes that ‘a wide range of methods may be applied to the problems which Nexus seeks to address. They are both qualitative and quantitative, and are drawn from the full range of academic disciplines. Researchers will need training in choosing the right method as well as in using it. Mixed methods are likely to be appropriate for many Nexus-related problems.’

About the report

The report was compiled by the independent science writer Martin Ince, as a record of the concerns and issues discussed at the workshop, and to highlight some approaches that might be of value to participants in the network and with related interests. This report is not the ‘minutes of the meeting’, but is intended to capture the diversity of discussions that took place at the workshop. Although the workshop was not designed to produce a specific set of recommendations, the report does draw out concerns and priorities which emerged as possible topics for future discussion. The report does not necessarily reflect the views of the Nexus Network or of individual workshop participants.

Download the full report

To read more about the workshop discussions, download the full report as a pdf Transdisciplinary Nexus Methods Workshop final Report 2015

 

Image credit. With thanks to Christian Meyer (Street Photography) on flickr.

Sep 2, 2015 The Nexus Network
Tweet
Follow @uk_nexus
8 years ago about, partners, peoplemethods, transdisciplinary, workshop3,012
The Nexus Network
Research paper on tracing the water-energy-food nexusWhat is transdisciplinarity?
You Might Also Like
 
Political dimensions of the nexus
 
Methods workshop talks

Nexus logo social

Nexus Network on Twitter
Tweets by @
Explore the site
Info

Research coordinator: Cian O’Donovan

Communications and engagement: Becky Ayre

Read our privacy policy here.

Accessibility Statement

 

about the nexus network

The Nexus Network has been a linked investment from the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) in the UK, supporting a community of researchers and stakeholders to tackle nexus interdependencies, trade-offs and decision-making processes. Read more.

2015- 2018. The Nexus Network. Website designed, developed and maintained by Atoms and Bits.
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish.Accept Reject Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Functional
Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
Performance
Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
Analytics
Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
Advertisement
Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
Others
Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
SAVE & ACCEPT